As agreed with pastor mike conn, i here begin the first of three articles on the subject of modalism, or, more correctly, modalistic monarchianism. Jul 11, 2011 swedenborgs modalism then is a modalism of expansion rather than sequential manifestation, and it is similar to what we find beginning to happen in the book of mormon, although joseph does not seem as clearly settled on this solution, since he has left room for a sequential modalism at places like the baptism and descent to the new world. The socalled dynamic monarchians were actually a form of adoptionism. Ancient teachers of dynamic monarchianism were theodotians, a tanner in byzantium around 190 a. Denial of the trinity, assertion that there is only one divine person, who appears in three different roles. Why modalism is a damnable heresy in light of the recent t. Swedenborgs modalism then is a modalism of expansion rather than sequential manifestation, and it is similar to what we find beginning to happen in the book of mormon, although joseph does not seem as clearly settled on this solution, since he has left room for a sequential modalism at places like the baptism and descent to the new world. The 3c witnessed the monarchian controversy o monarchianism. It is alive and well today in some varieties of pentecostalism. There are no churches that identify themselves as modalists, and arguably there never were. Modalistic monarchianism is a christian theology that upholds the oneness of god as well as.
This is the theory that there is one and only one god but he appears at various times in different modes, sometimes as the father, sometimes as the son, sometimes as the holy spirit. I think classic modalism is fraught with heretical issues central being the denial is the distinct existence of god as father, son. Monarchianism, properly speaking, refers to the modalists. Avoiding the achilles heel of modalistic monarchianism.
His charge that modalism has no mediator one mode of god could not mediate to another mode of god, bc, pp1 is a pretense that modalism denies the humanity of christ see bc, pp2, 4, 26. Monarchianism, in christianity, a christological position that opposed the doctrine of an independent, personal subsistence of the logos and affirmed the sole deity of god the father. Thus, it represented the extreme monotheistic view though it regarded jesus christ as redeemer, it clung to the numerical unity of the deity. In its most general sense monarchianism also called patripassianism or sabellianism refers to the primarily western attempts in the third century to defend monotheism against suspected tritheism by denying the personal distinctiveness of a divine son and holy spirit in contrast to god the father. This first article will be kept to under 3,000 words, as will the next two offerings.
Todays study describes a heresy known as either modalistic monarchianism or. Modal monarchianism teaches that the father, the son, and the holy spirit are just modes of the single person who is god. The doctrinal heresy known as modalistic monarchianism modalism, patripassianism, or sabellianism is commonly attributed to sabellius ad 250. Nov 18, 2016 what did the prenicene christians believe about the teaching that god is one god in one person also called monarchiamism.
The sect probably died out about the middle of the third century, and can never have been numerous. Oneness theology modalism was the predominant view of. Analogies that compare god to water vapor, liquid, and ice are also essentially modalistic, even though most people who think of god this way are probably not aware that they are thinking. Modalism called oneness in the twentyfirst century teaches the full deity of jesus and his full humanity as well. Todays study describes a heresy known as either modalistic monarchianism or modalism. Thirdly, some trinitarians scholars cite hippolytuss book, against all heresies book 9, chapter 5 to show that modalism originated from heraclitus a pagan greek philosopher from 535475 bc. Also known as modalistic monarchianism, this heretical view. Monarchianism is a christian theology that emphasizes god as one, in direct contrast to. He emphasizes that jesus is god, but he was the created human manifestation of god, the father robed in flesh.
Stephen nichols, in his excellent book for us and for our salvation. Jan 02, 2020 a monarchian believes in the unity of god the latin word monarchia meant single rule to the point that he denies gods triune nature. Modalistic monarchianism or modalism considers god to be one while. This paper attempts to address a proper understanding of the correct placement and application of the distinctions made in scripture between the father and the son, and how this affects oneness theology and hermeneutics. These works are of monumental historical significance, not because they rightly elucidate the doctrine of the trinity, but because they provide the first major systematic treatment of semi modalism, and unfortunately, helped to popularize it. The book of mormon displays smiths monarchianmonotheism. Monarchianism synonyms, monarchianism pronunciation, monarchianism translation, english dictionary definition of monarchianism. It is a form of monarchianism and as such stands in contrast with trinitarianism.
Hippolytus, rather, was a champion of the logos doctrine that distinguished the persons of the trinity. The best historical evidence indicates that ignatius was appointed the third bishop of antioch by one of the apostles likely john and that he was. Modalism is a term coined, and used most commonly by trinitarianism to refer to what is known today as the oneness view, which was branded as. The monarchian prologues to the gospels found in most old mss. Modalistic monarchianism considers god to be one while working through the different modes or. Along with maintaining this principle, the modalistic monarchians also wanted to. Monarchianism, sabellianism, patripassionism, modalism advanced information. Sep 07, 2016 the best historical evidence indicates that ignatius was appointed the third bishop of antioch by one of the apostles likely john and that he was mentored by the apostle john himself. Modalism or modalistic monarchianism considers god to be a single. Bernard proves his point by giving references in both the old and new testament. Response to jason dulles avoiding the achilles heel of modalistic monarchianism dr. Modalistic monarchian definition is an adherent of modalistic monarchianism.
Hippolytus falsely charged that noetus and other monarchian teachers received their teachings from a fifth century bc greek philosopher named heraclitus. The 3c witnessed the monarchian controversy o monarchianism stressed the axiom from relg 334 at mcgill university. Monarchian trinitarianism states that if jesus is really, truly, or properly gods son, this must entail the son sharing a generic nature, genus, or species with god the father, since this is the case in all generation that takes place within creation. Modalism and sabellianism are synonymous terms used to describe this false doctrine on the nature of god. Though it regarded jesus christ as redeemer, it clung to the. Modalistic monarchianism considers god to be one while working through the different modes or manifestations of father, son, and holy spirit. Other articles where modalistic monarchianism is discussed. Since the nt is clear enough that father, son and the holy spirit are each fully god, the bible student is challenged by these distinctions and how to harmonize them with the monotheism of the ot, which is clearly monarchian. These works are of monumental historical significance, not because they rightly elucidate the doctrine of the trinity, but because they provide the first major systematic treatment of semi. Modalistic monarchianism definition is monarchianism holding that jesus christ was not a distinct person of the trinity but was rather one of three successive modes or manifestations of god. Jakes controversy and modalism i decided to write this article to better explain the problem with this heresy. Monarchianism, sabellianism, patripassianism, modalism.
Its characteristic tenet, that god the father and jesus are one person, was developed in two forms in early christianity. In godhead theology bishop jerry hayes follows that debate through the first 300 years of the churchs history. Sabellius, monotheist, modalist, monarchian, patripassian. Following this view, all the godhead is understood to dwell in the person of jesus from the incarnation. Monarchianism definition of monarchianism by the free. Librorum prohibitorum depicts the holy ghost supplying the book burning. Modalism monarchianism encyclopedic dictionary of bible. Modalistic monarchian definition of modalistic monarchian. To state early christians didnt believe in the trinity is to assume the point to be proved. Overlooked, in this charge is the dual nature of jesus which allows for the humanity of christ to be the human mediator between god and mankind. He wrote a book entitled observations concerning the scripture economy of. Modal monarchianism see what is modalism below teaches that the father, the son, and the holy spirit are just three modes of the single person who is god. The historical record indicates that arians and semiarians condemned sabellian modalism in antioch in about 264272 a. In between trinitarianism and unitarianism is modalism or monarchian modalism or even modalistic monarchianism.
Modalism, also called sabellianism, is the unorthodox belief that god is one person who has revealed himself in three forms or modes in contrast to the trinitarian doctrine where god is one being eternally existing in three persons. The terms father and son are then used to describe the distinction between the transcendence. Both modalism and monarchianism, in an attempt to reconcile the seeming contradiction between the trinity and monotheism, maintained that in god there are no distinct persons, the father, the son, and the holy spirit being simply modes or manifestations of a single divine person. Augustine wrote at great length on the trinity, a total of 15 volumes. Thus, it represented the extreme monotheistic view. Oneness theology modalism was the predominant view of the. Monarchianism definition, any of several doctrines of the christian church in the 2nd and 3rd centuries a. Why modalism is a damnable heresy ehuds 18 inch dagger.
In fact modalism, is historically unrecorded until it made its first debut through sabellius. Any of several christian doctrines of the second and third centuries ad that attempted to maintain monotheism and the unity of the godhead, thereby. What did the prenicene christians believe about the teaching that god is one god in one person also called monarchiamism. Modalistic monarchianism or modalism considers god to be one while appearing and working through the different modes of father, son, and holy spirit. Jan 16, 2018 augustine wrote at great length on the trinity, a total of 15 volumes. Priscillian was an extreme monarchian and so was commodian carmen apol. Hippolytus, the rome gadfly, stirring up theological accusations, the usurping antipope, who hated monarchian modalism, claimed noetus was a follower of heraclitus, on account he was alleged to have taught the union of the opposites when he taught god was both visible and invisible in jesus and passible could suffer death and impassible. Monarchian article about monarchian by the free dictionary. Corssen to a roman author of the time of callistus, but they are almost certainly the work of priscillian. Both modalism and monarchianism inevitably hold to the doctrine of patripassianism, the teaching that god the father suffered on the cross with or as the son, and are closely related to sabellianism. Section one is the history of the early church from a.
This article has been split into four separate articles. Too many times christians have no clue how to explain why modalism is a damnable heresy because they do not understand its conclusions. Corssen they were written at rome about thirty years after the muratorian fragment in monarchian circles. This book goes into detail and explains that modalism is consistently monotheism. Modalism is the denial of the trinity and the affirmation that instead god exists as just one eternal person who takes on three different modes or roles as he relates to creation at different times. Modalism, tritheism, or the pure revelation of the triune god.
Modalism is a term coined, and used most commonly by trinitarianism to refer to what is known today as the oneness view, which was branded as a heresy by the catholic church in ancient times. However, its basic elements can be traced back as far as ad 200 to praxeas of asia minor, ad 230 to noetus of smyrna, and ad 250 to beryll of bostra. Modalism is the belief that god, rather than being three persons, is one person who reveals himself in three modes, much as an actor might play three roles in a movie. A monarchian believes in the unity of god the latin word monarchia meant single rule to the point that he denies gods triune nature. Modalism defined the essential idea of this school of thought is that there is one god, which may be variously designated as father, son, or spirit. What are sabellianism, modalism, and monarchianism.
Modalism monarchianism synonyms, modalism monarchianism pronunciation, modalism monarchianism translation, english dictionary definition of modalism monarchianism. The discussion will start with a definition of modalism, cover the history of the heresy, and then move to an apologetic against the doctrine of modalism. Modalism and monarchianism are two false views of the nature of god and of jesus the christ that appeared in the second and third centuries ad. Quasten writes, there is a series of longer prologues to the gospels, the socalled monarchian prologues, which used to be assigned to the first half of the third century.
691 1329 1535 1473 1481 233 1438 390 1320 998 873 657 234 1438 1464 1083 852 551 255 1187 1193 762 1299 654 193 540 1126 570